In exchange for skipping out on 9 days in Tent City, I had to endure 36 hours of alcohol counseling. This is certainly faster and easier, but I’m hard-pressed to declare it is better. Tent City was boring, mildly surreal, and humiliating in a very impersonal way. Counseling fills me with rage, its phantasmagorical like some of Ken Kesey’s trippiest passages from “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest,” and intimately offensive.
Counseling is not there to actually help you, or understand you, or talk through the whole experience of DUI. If it was, the counselors would have MDs or be licensed psychiatrists. They would allow you to talk about all aspects of the experience to help you find any valid concept to grow from your wrongdoing and avoid making the mistake again in the future. They would not cover everyone with a blanket set of determinations, and attempt to diagnose you all with the same information. In reality, the counselors are all ex-alcoholics or Mormons, who are there only to proselytize a religion that is entrenched in their oligarchy: you drank, therefore, you have a problem.
The untenable position of objectively defining a problem that can only be seen by its negative results, and attempting to project negative results when only the one DUI is there to form a pattern, thwarts them from the start. Yes, I made a very bad mistake. And yes, it was not the first time. That makes me a lawbreaker, a person lacking respect for alcohol and a car and the authority of law, it does not make me an addict. They love to say how if you’ve done it once you’ve gotten away with it many times, and if you have done it there are hidden perils beneath your surface. But without results to back up these theories, it begs the question of exactly what is the problem? The problem is defined by counselors, who’s very job is an inherent conflict of interest, since they both assign and clear you from your program, and have a financial interest in the hours you are assigned to attend. They of course follow “guidelines” in assigning you sessions, but the guidelines are written by these same experts.
Each session I hear the exact same phrases and symptoms that they spew, and go through their checklist not finding any positives other than the one instance.
- You are more likely to become an addict if you have parents who are addicts, suffered childhood trauma, or are fundamentally narcissistic. Nope, unless blogging qualifies as narcissism.
- You close down the bars and go looking for an after-bar party. I never go out with kids anyway.
- You call up your day-drinking buddies to fill the time. Day drinking? I have a highly productive job. When I do drink during the day, I’m usually doing chores and yardwork on a weekend, or watching football along with 100M other Americans.
- You drink more than 2 drinks at a time (for men), or 1 for women. Apparently just about everyone I know is a high-level functioning alcoholic.
- You’ve shut down emotionally. I could never conceive of the depths and complexities of emotion I have felt as a result of my children, and my 2.5 years writing about them is a better history of me than the counselor’s stupid 20 minute intake interview. Oh wait, see the part about narcissism.
Apparently I am in denial.
The D word has come up with each of the 6 dipshits I have had the pleasure of talking to. It usually takes less than 15 minutes before they bust it out, dropping it like f-bombs in a Three Six Mafia lyric. Angry about the draconian AZ laws? You are in denial about your problem. Bored with the class? You are in denial about your problem. Feel your punishment was excessive for its impact? Denial denial denial. Its a deus ex machina the counselors parade out whenever logic fails them. The beauty of controlling the definitions is that it makes their definers beyond reproach. One of my responses to this whole ordeal has been to study the law and work to change aspects of it I consider unfair, thereby communicating and sharing with others, engaging the political process, and turning my anger into constructive energy. One particular Nurse Ratched all-knowingly asserted that this is all denial, because I should really be focusing my energy on improving myself and my problem. The circularity of that logic is really quite elegant.
The fact is the counselors are not interested in your opinions, or connecting with you, or debating; they are coming for your mind. Session after session, week after week, they are trying to drill into you that you are a bad person. Shame Training. The classes take 1 full weekend, and 5 weeks with 2 sessions a week. If you just sit there and nod and fade into the background, they are easy to get through and generally let out early. And I have tried, making the practice of shutting my mouth and displaying a convert’s facade my little self-improvement project for the time I am wasting in these sessions – the skill surely will come in handy in the future. But docility is not my mindset and never has been, and since my mind is what they are attacking, the classes have been a bitter struggle for me.
The ironies and contradictions in counseling stink like cat piss in a carpet. They talk about projection and thinking errors, how throughout our lives everything we are told and embrace is the subjective opinions of others that may lead us to devalue ourselves and become addicts, yet they do not see the lunacy in their projecting a truth about us having problems with substance abuse. One obese counselor talked about her food addiction replacing her drug habit while trying to humiliate us for our arrests. Another talked about her difficulty maintaining control of her car texting while driving, yet flew into a rage when people were speaking out against AZ’s DUI law that can send you to jail for being 50 feet from your car if you’ve been drinking. We saw a video about a lifetime whino and his 500 arrests, and the counselors spoke of how the system failed him, how he needed help. I guess first time offenders get punished and shamed, and only when you’ve fucked your life up so irretrievably do you get their sympathy instead of scorn. They mention how only 10% of the people who go through 12 step programs are successful, how opiates and meth recidivism rates are upwards of 95%, they say 60% of the people who get DUIs in AZ will get another and the median time is only 3.5 years! Yet still they sit on their folding-chairs thrones, and lord over the counseling sessions as they polish their halos.
What I’ve come to realize is that these people live for rehashing your misery, they are utterly and totally invested in wallowing in your problem, and it speaks more about their addictions than yours. They are in denial about their own codependencies, but they get very very defensive when you turn the scalpel of analysis back on them. They don’t often encounter someone with my IQ, my degree in philosophy, my lively mind, and my ability to push buttons just like them. One of them stopped calling on me for awhile, another threatened to kick me out and send me to Tent City. The most saccharine scene was when we went around the room and spoke about a trait of an addict we felt we displayed, and the counselor practically creamed herself with elation after each person’s breakthrough. The irony and the melodrama were only enhanced in that she let each person leave early as a reward for their soul-bearing confession. After the first guy was cut loose, 20 people couldn’t raise their hands fast enough. Outside the class, a guy who had just revealed his empowered feeling in having not smoked for several weeks offered to sell me weed.
The sessions are not all bad. There is some useful information to be learned about the laws, how to avoid getting caught and mistakes not to make, coping strategies so you don’t do it again, and the realization that you are not a pariah and you are not the worst person out there. They insist you don’t drink or smoke during the ~6 weeks the sessions have taken me, and in cutting out pot and cutting down beer to avoid the 80hr detection window I have reinforced some good habits about not mixing drinking and driving. There are people in there who do feel they have problems and are looking for help. I feel sorry for them that they are forced to be in classes with me, and I feel sorry for me that I am forced to be in classes with them. Another flaw in the design of the system.
Unfortunately, the positives in the class are in reality just the bait-and-switch for the counselors’ reproach and ignominy that fill you with self-doubt. Most of us are affected enough by the awful experience of a DUI arrest that we are genuinely trying to find a lesson and some meaning in it all, and into that breach the counselors plunge. Like sect leaders or military recruiters, they prey on your vulnerabilities and your moments of weakness while you are their captive audience. In the workplace this is called harassment, at home its called molestation, in public its called cult brainwashing. In Arizona its called treatment. It fucks with your head, it makes you begin to see yourself as their addiction statistic when you are trapped and can not raise your own voice for your own affirmation. But on their side they have the inarguable fact that if you don’t drink, you don’t get a DUI. If they packaged the message in a way that was supportive and positive, rather than confrontational and humiliating, it would be such a better use of the 36 wasted hours. If I could have the time back to pick up trash at the park, to talk to other adults about the consequences of my mistake, to communicate with the other class members without the disingenuous counselors in the room, it would be time better spent.
When I was a freshman in high school we had these month-long 1-act plays in the drama club during the spring, after the “big Spring production”. The idea was you got to try something different in theater. I got to be the tech director, but that is not significant. I worked on a play called “The Insanity of Mary Girard” which was kinda cheesy and probably easy for a high school to pull off. It was abstract, attempting to anthropomorphize the “forces of society” in declaring a woman insane when she was not. I liked it, and not just cause I got to hang out with the seniors and go to their parties. The notion has always seemed so obvious to me, and even at a young age it resonated deeply with me – how those in power create the definitions, how the disempowered are disenfranchised, the inequalities between the haves and the have-nots, history is written by the victors etc etc etc. Its a clarity I’ve had my entire life, developed as a teenager, maybe even earlier – when I was about 4 my parents brought me to several sessions with a psychiatrist because I had a natural aversion to authority. Every day after Shame Training I have come home and plinked away at this post as a means of catharsis and cleansing my mind, and now with just 3 sessions and 8 days from finishing, my anger is gone and replaced mostly by amused boredom. The education is not about me anymore, its about the blunt tools those in power use to try to define you, and how fighting them is not about logic but about misdirection. When the last class ends, as the counselor is printing my certificate, I am going to place a takeout order for the Blue Nile Cafe, eat it while I have my first party hat in 6 weeks, wake from this horrible dream like Chief Bromden, and get stoked for the Crazy 88 that weekend.